An argument, an angry text message, or a confrontation with another person can sometimes lead to criminal charges in Connecticut. When police become involved, conduct that might have started as a personal dispute can result in allegations of threatening, harassment, or both. For people facing threatening and/or harassment charges in Waterbury, it’s important to understand what exactly Connecticut law requires prosecutors to prove for a conviction.
In Connecticut, prosecutors can bring separate charges for threatening someone with physical harm (threatening) and engaging in communications intended to harass, alarm, or terrorize another person (harassment). The circumstances surrounding an incident, the words or actions involved, and the defendant’s intent can all affect whether the evidence supports a criminal conviction. Our Connecticut criminal defense attorneys will evaluate the facts of your case and develop the strongest possible defense to the allegations against you.
At the Sills Law Firm, we understand that criminal accusations can have serious consequences for your reputation, employment, and future. We take a proactive approach to criminal defense, working to resolve cases outside of court whenever possible. Reach out to our law offices today to schedule a free initial consultation with a Waterbury criminal defense lawyer.
What Is The Difference Between Threatening and Harassment in Connecticut?
Threatening and harassment are separate offenses under Connecticut law. While the charges can arise from the same dispute, prosecutors must establish different legal elements for each offense.
Generally, threatening can be charged when a person threatens another person with physical injury or violence. Harassment is a bit different, as it is charged when a person uses a communication device with an intent to cause annoyance or alarm.
For example, a prosecutor may charge someone with harassment if they threaten to seriously injure another person during a face-to-face confrontation. If a person calls someone else repeatedly, sends constant text messages, or otherwise communicates with them in a way that is designed to annoy them, a prosecutor could charge them with harassment.
However, an angry statement or an unwanted message will not automatically result in a criminal charge. To convict a person of a crime like threatening or harassment, a prosecutor must establish the elements of the specific charge. As Connecticut criminal defense attorneys, our role is to argue that the state cannot establish these elements beyond a reasonable doubt.
What Must Prosecutors Prove in a Threatening Case?
In Connecticut, there are two separate threatening charges that a prosecutor may bring:
- Threatening in the Second Degree: A person may be convicted of this offense if a prosecutor can prove that they:
- Intentionally place or attempt to place another person in fear of imminent serious physical injury by physical threat;
- Threaten to commit any crime of violence with the intent to terrorize another person or threaten to commit a crime of violence with reckless disregard for the risk of causing such terror; or
- Engage in the above conduct and the person threatened is in a house of religious worship, a religiously-affiliated community center, or a school or daycare.
Threatening in the second degree is a Class A misdemeanor, except that if the person threatened is in a place listed above, it will be charged as a Class D felony.
- Threatening in the First Degree: A person may be charged with threatening in the first degree if they:
- Threaten to commit any crime involving the use of a hazardous substance with the intent to terrorize another person, to cause evacuation of a building, place of assembly, or facility of transportation, or cause serious public inconvenience, or if they threaten to commit such a crime with reckless disregard of these potential consequences;
- Threatens to commit any crime of violence with the intent to cause evacuation of a building, place of assembly, or facility of transportation, or cause serious public inconvenience, or does so with reckless disregard of causing such an outcome;
- Commits threatening in the second degree while armed or representing themselves to be armed; or
- Threatens to commit a crime with the intent of causing an evacuation of a house of religious worship, a religiously-affiliated community center, or a school or daycare.
Threatening in the first degree is a Class D felony, but may be charged as a Class C felony if the intent is to cause an evacuation of the places listed above.
Importantly, not every statement made during an argument or in the heat of the moment will constitute a criminal threat. Context matters when determining if the alleged threat is a crime. A true threat has to be distinguished from exaggeration, joking, or bluster.
For example, a couple is having an argument when one person makes an angry remark. In this situation, it will be important to distinguish between a serious expression of an intent to cause harm or just a statement made out of frustration. The prosecution will be required to prove not only that the statement was made, but that it was done with a specific intent for a desired outcome.
Threatening allegations are not uncommon in domestic violence cases. If you are facing a threatening charge related to an allegation of domestic abuse, the potential consequences may be serious. It is critical to have experienced legal representation to protect your rights.
What Must Prosecutors Prove in a Harassment Case?
There are two potential harassment charges in Connecticut:
- Harassment in the Second Degree: A person can be charged with harassment in the second degree if, with no legitimate purpose and the intent to harass, terrorize, or alarm another person, they:
- Communicate with a person by mail, telegraph, electronically, or by phone, in a manner that is likely to cause terror, intimidation, or alarm;
- Make a telephone call or engage in any other form of communication in a manner that is likely to cause terror, intimidation, or alarm; or
- Communicate or share a photograph, video, words, or any other communication to a digital, electronic, online, or other meeting space, in a manner likely to cause terror, intimidation, or alarm.
Harassment in the second degree is a class C misdemeanor.
- Harassment in the First Degree: A person can be charged with harassment in the first degree when, with the intent to harass, annoy, alarm, or terrorize another person, they communicate a threat to kill or injure another person by telephone, telegraph, mail, computer network, or any other form of written communication, and they have been previously convicted of certain offenses.
Harassment in the first degree is a class D felony.
Harassment laws do not mean that a person can never have an unpleasant conversation or send a communication that is unwanted. Instead, prosecutors are required to prove both intent and lack of legitimate purpose when pursuing these charges.
For example, consider a situation where a person sends multiple texts to someone during a disagreement. The fact that the recipient did not like the messages doesn’t necessarily mean that the sender can be charged with harassment. The content, context, and purpose of the communications are all critical to the question of whether a crime occurred.
What Evidence Can Prosecutors Use in a Connecticut Threatening or Harassment Case?
In Waterbury, a prosecutor can use a range of evidence to prove a threatening or harassment charge. This may include:
- Text messages and social media communications: Investigators may review message content, timestamps, account information, and the surrounding conversation. Complete message histories can be important because an excerpt of communications may not accurately reflect the full exchange.
- Witness statements: The alleged recipient of the threats or harassment, people who witnessed a confrontation, and others may be asked to provide a statement or testify.
- Audio or video recordings: Phone recordings, surveillance footage, or other recordings may establish what occurred and provide context.
- Call logs and digital records: These records can establish whether communications occurred, when they occurred, and how frequently they took place.
- Statements made to police: Statements made by the defendant may become part of the state’s evidence. That is why it is never a good idea to talk to law enforcement without first consulting with an attorney.
Of course, this evidence could also be potentially used to disprove threatening or harassment charges. For example, a call log could show that the alleged victim and the defendant were actually exchanging phone calls. A recording of an argument from a bystander might reveal that the defendant was actually laughing when he made what is being charged as a threat.
Defending Against Threatening and Harassment Charges
The burden is on the state to prove every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. As Connecticut criminal defense attorneys, we will fight to defend you and protect your rights. Depending on the facts of the case, we might employ one of the following defenses:
- The Conduct Does Not Meet the Statutory Definition: A central question in any criminal case is whether the conduct described by the prosecution actually satisfies the elements of the charged offense. An offensive statement, heated argument, or unwanted message does not automatically establish criminal threatening or harassment. Our team may challenge whether the alleged words or actions meet the legal definition of the charged crime.
- The Required Intent Cannot Be Established: Threatening and harassment charges require either proof of a specific intent or proof of reckless disregard for a particular outcome. The prosecution has to prove the applicable mental state for the charge that you are facing. The conversation as a whole, your actions, and other evidence can potentially prove that you did not have the intent required.
- The Communications Had a Legitimate Purpose: For harassment in the second degree, the prosecution must prove that you did not have a legitimate purpose for making the communications. If you communicated with the other person for a valid reason, it might be a defense to the charge. For example, if you texted your ex repeatedly about child custody issues, that might be considered a legitimate purpose.
- The Evidence Is Incomplete or Unreliable: Messages presented without the surrounding conversation, inconsistent witness accounts, or inaccurate recordings may create issues with the reliability of the state’s evidence. Our team can investigate the source and completeness of the evidence and argue that the charges should be dismissed.
- First Amendment Issues: The First Amendment protects many forms of expression, including speech that is angry, critical, or offensive. However, that protection does not extend to every statement or communication. If you have been charged with threatening or harassment, we will determine whether your speech was actually constitutionally protected.
A conviction for threatening or harassment can come with serious consequences, particularly if it is charged as a felony. Even misdemeanor convictions can result in jail time, fines, and other penalties. Our Connecticut criminal defense attorneys will thoroughly analyze your case to put together the strongest possible defense to the charges against you.
Talk to a Waterbury Criminal Defense Lawyer
Threatening and harassment charges can arise from any number of situations, including fairly complicated interpersonal disputes. If you have been arrested for a communication that you made to another person, it is important to remember that it is still possible to defend against the charges. The state is required to prove every element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt to secure a conviction.
The Sills Law Firm represents individuals facing criminal allegations in Connecticut. If you have been arrested or charged with threatening or harassment in Waterbury, we can help you understand the charges, evaluate the evidence, and determine the best course of action based on the facts of your case. To learn more or to schedule a free initial consultation with a Connecticut criminal defense attorney, call our law offices at 866-971-5795 or fill out our online contact form.






